Old Bones Or New Beginnings?

The decision between renovation and rebuilding is a tricky one. Should you tear it all down and start anew? Or work with your original footprint and liven it up from there? Western Australia Home Design and Living’s Hannah McDonald sits down with Bernie Cronyn, director of Elaborate Design Homes, to answer the age-old debate: to renovate, or to rebuild? That is the question.

Elaborate Design Homes

Cronyn began in the industry as a floor and wall tiler with a particular passion for stonework. With nothing to lose and knowledge to gain, he set his sights on furthering his education and broadening his horizons. “Out of ignorance, not knowing enough about the construction industry, I studied and completed my Building Diploma,” he recalls. Now, with years of experience and a highly involved accreditation under his belt, he commits himself wholeheartedly to every job with the skills and attention to detail necessary. “I like to immerse myself in each project from the preparation stages, right through to completion, meaning I am onsite and heavily involved throughout the projects,” he promises.

When it comes to the clients unsure of whether to renovate or rebuild, Cronyn advises that early communication is the best method to ensure expectations are met. “We begin with a discussion of what the client’s needs and visions are and whether the existing footprint is conducive to their desired outcome,” he identifies. Several other factors however, come into play when making the right decision for your project. Cronyn breaks down all the elements that require consideration.

REASONS TO RENOVATE

Renovations are a popular choice for clients whose homes possess a footprint they do not wish to change. Another reason a homeowner may opt for a renovation, is if the home has historical elements they wish to preserve. “If an existing home has certain qualities and attributes that should be respected depending on the period of time that they were constructed, or the layout works for the client, but needs to be extended, then a renovation is most favourable. But if the entire design needs to change considerably, I suggest rebuilding,” he advises.

Elaborate Design Homes

Renovating a historical home provides you with a sophisticated, opulent space that cannot be replicated with an entirely new build. Cronyn reiterates, “if you decide to renovate a home with character, it is important to pay respect to the existing architectural features by designing and constructing items that complement and reflect those. This will make the project timeless and retain its class.”

Another reason to choose renovation over rebuilding is to maintain not only historical features, but elements within the home that are personal and beloved by the inhabitants. “In my experience, this happens a lot with unique features, as its almost paying homage to the existing architecture,” he says. In summation, for historical building and homes with personality that deeply connect with the owners, renovation is the perfect choice. However, old buildings are also at risk of structural issues that need to be accounted for. “The major influence would be the structural integrity of the existing building and whether the new structure can be supported by this,” he explains.

 

Elaborate Design Homes

REASONS TO REBUILD

For many clients, rebuilding is the go-to option. It allows the space to be completely reimagined, which in many cases, provides more value to the overall project. “People often assume a renovation is cheaper, when in fact it can more expensive. This is contributed to by the deconstruction process, the changes made and then the make good. Typically, a full knockdown and rebuild would be the most cost effective if there are to be major changes to the original design,” he emphasises.

Rebuilding is also more time efficient. By starting from scratch, the possibility of unearthing unexpected structures that derail the project is completely removed. “Renovations are generally longer, due to so many incidental, make good items. You are never starting with a blank canvas; there can be hidden surprises when you’re working with something that is already existing. There can be structural surprises, and not all of these are evident before the demolition process,” he observes.

Cronyn recounts a situation in which the client opted for a renovation instead of a rebuild, costing him more in the end but retaining the original, front-facing façade. “I believe all our clients have made a correct decision based on their circumstances. However, there was one project which would have been easier and cheaper to completely rebuild, but the clients wished to keep original footprint, particularly the front façade in keeping with the surrounding neighbourhood. This client didn’t make an incorrect decision, just a more expensive one,” he recalls.

MAKING THE RIGHT CALL

For those in the decision phase of their project, Cronyn offers some pieces of advice, drawing on his wealth of experience. For clients, he suggests, “I would advise them to thoroughly explore their vision and exactly what it is they are trying to achieve. From there we could make the decision on what would be best for them; renovate or rebuild.” He expands to describe the myriad ways changing lifestyles can affect what people want from a project, and how this can influence the decision between renovate and rebuild. In his experience, there are “people wanting more bedrooms and bathrooms to suit extended families. And in older clients, wanting to increase the timeline of their existing home, by installing lifts, larger rooms and wider doorways.” All of these factors affect what is more suitable – renovation or rebuilding. In summary, Cronyn advocates for creative thinking, communication and realistic expectations in the decision phase of your project. “You’re only limited by your imagination and your budget,” he concludes.

Images courtesy of Elaborate Design Homes